]> snarfed.org draw group stream of consciousness Ryan Barrett <snarfed at ryanb dot org> en text/html Copyright 2002-2007 Ryan Barrett Are MMOGs Team Sports? Ryan Barrett <snarfed at ryanb dot org> 2007-08-13T09:03:00Z en text/html Copyright 2002-2007 Ryan Barrett

I love games. I love game development, gaming culture, games as an art form, and the game industry.

I don't have much time to play games, though, so my firsthand experience is somewhat spotty. For example, I've never really played an MMOG. So when I found myself talking with a friend and coworker who plays WoW, I jumped at the chance to pick his brain.

He plays with a high-level raiding guild, so he spends most of his time in large groups of 10 to 25 people. I was fascinated to hear how much teamwork the group raids require. Each person has a specific role, and each is vital to the group as a whole. The group members all support and depend on each other, coordinating tactics with split-second timing at critical moments.

Granted, multiplayer FPSes and RTSes have always demanded skills like these. Games like Counter-Strike and Starcraft series have established ladders and tournaments, and leagues like CPL and CGS have turned the best teams into professional organizations. Top Counter-Strike teams keep strict training regimens, run tactical drills, and study their opponents' game footage before matches.

I'd never considered MMOGs in the same vein, though. My friend plays ice hockey as well as WoW (friend: 1, stereotype: 0), so I asked him what he thought of the team sport analogy. He saw the parallels, but he said they didn't quite feel the same.

He described his hockey team as much more tight-knight and consistent than his WoW guild, which is fairly big and loose. He plays hockey with more or less the same people every week. By comparison, his WoW raid one night might only have a few people in common with the group the next night.

He also mentioned the difference in immersion. Unlike hockey, even the most difficult raids in WoW don't always require his full attention. Whether it's his girlfriend (friend: 2, stereotype: 0), his phone, or his dog, real life can interrupt WoW much more easily than hockey. (Interestingly, he said his team's adoption of TeamSpeak both added and detracted from the game's immersion. The always-on voice communication made his teammates feel much more present, but it also exposed him to many of their interruptions.)

OK, so even in large group raids with a top-tier guild, WoW might not rise to the level of good hockey game. Still, it's far beyond the grinding, socializing, and gold farming that the rest of us usually associate with MMOGs. That alone was enlightening.

Personally, I think this speaks to games' untapped potential as an art form. With the more static art forms - film, literature, music - the basic experience doesn't change much. In a game, though, interactivity means the basic experience can vary widely. There's the team sport experience, but there's also problem solving, socializing, creation, storytelling, strategizing, role playing, and my personal favorite, exploration.

So far, the game industry has taken only half-hearted steps toward realizing this potential. It's spent the bulk of its effort iterating on the same tired themes: racing, fighting, shooting, sports, and adventure. Recently, though, we've seen the rise of more unusual themes. Socializing, for one. Music, medicine, and law, to name a few others. Emotion may well be next.

Personally, I think this is awesome. Microsoft, are you listening? Sony? EA? Activision? Bring on the new experiences, and I'll fork over the dough. I can't wait, and I know I'm not the only one.

Related links:

 http://snarfed.org/ Are MMOGs Team Sports? maulik cmt_pubDate text/html WoW ... Stereotypes really got pwned in this post ...

It sounds like my basketball crew is more like a WoW guild than your friend's hockey team. There are a core set of players and a few randoms mixed in. From time to time, a random subset of our crew plays a an entire team of randoms. The randoms can all be bigger, faster, and better shots, but they get shredded by our little band of players simply because of teamwork. My point is that in the continuum of teamwork between WoW and a real sports team, I would agree there's a lot of game-play value there.

Now we switch to a different point, that I will combine with the first in a second.

We've been playing Fifa07 a bit and have found that in a 1 vs. 2 match, the one wins -- the teamwork controls are kind of random. On top of that, my friend said that he'd never buy Fifa08 because he has Fifa07. He made this decision because he was thinking about graphics. I asked him if he'd buy it if there were significant gameplay improvements, he said he probably would.

Now for the denouement, if publishers improved teamwork gameplay instead of graphics, more people would buy more games.

Now that you have two friends who play a sport and a videogame, does stereotype get a point?