Hi all! It’s been a while since my last status update on Bridgy Fed, its upcoming Bluesky/AT Protocol support, and the resulting firestorm.
It’s coming along! It’s not launched yet, I still have a number of things to build and tests to run, but it’s getting there. Also, Bluesky’s current federation test is limited to 10 users per federated server. We can’t launch until they lift that limit. I don’t know when that will happen, but I’m confident it will.
I’m also blocking launch on building the opt in/out prompt idea that came out of the blowup. Thank you all (and Kio!) again for that idea, I really do appreciate it. I wish I’d come up with it beforehand, would have saved everyone the headache. But it seems like this – getting feedback before launch and incorporating it – is the system working, at least in some ways, which is good.
The current design is that a Bridgy Fed instance actor (user) will DM you the first time anyone on Bluesky requests to follow or interact with you over the bridge. If you reply yes, or follow the Bridgy Fed user, you’ll be bridged. If you reply no, or ignore the DM, or block that user, you won’t be. You’ll also be able to follow or block the Bridgy Fed user to opt in or out proactively, ahead of time.
On a related note, I still think there’s a tension between the fediverse’s current default of open, opt-out federation and its culture of consent and opt-in. That tension is magnified by the fact that the fediverse has always been multi-protocol, not just ActivityPub but also OStatus, Diaspora, and Zot/Nomad, among others, so boundaries between networks have been fuzzy at best.
For people who want it, consent-based/opt-in federation is the most promising solution that I’ve heard so far. Beyond that, I don’t have any answers of my own, but there’s obviously been lots of discussion over the last couple months, which feels like a good sign.
As always, feedback is welcome!
Can’t wait! 🙏
@snarfed.org Is there a way in ActivityPub to automatically localize a DM to the recipient’s language? The fediverse (including Bluesky) is very multilingual in my experience, and its borderline spammy to indiscriminately send out cold DMs to people that are written in a language they can’t read.
@snarfed.org I love your thoughtfulness and hard work. I mean, I also have a concrete desire to follow at least one account on Bluesky, but even aside from that, you are setting a great example of tackling the hard questions.
📌
@snarfed.org Thank you for the update! The effort is very much appreciated – I am looking forward to this.
Will read. Meanwhile, thanks for hanging in there, Ryan. :)
Thank you for your service!
Liked a post by Ryan Barrett (snarfed.org)
O tom jsem četl, možná si tam i dával web, ale přišlo mi to docela složité. Evidentně ve mně rezonovala zkušenost s ActivityPubem. Každopádně díky